Most newborn toys do not need replacing at three months. Keep the rattle, cloth toy or suitable gym your baby still enjoys. If you are buying for the first time, I would choose one grasping toy, then decide whether you want a small washable crinkle toy or something larger to explore together on the floor.
The difference between three and six months can be substantial, so choose for what your baby can handle now. The CDC's four-month examples include holding a toy placed in the hand and swinging an arm at toys; reaching to grab a wanted toy appears on its six-month list. These are developmental observations, not skills a toy should make your baby perform.
Keep a suitable rattle, or choose a shape to try
If you need a grasping toy, the Teal Oball Rattle and the Original Winkel offer two different shapes. The Teal Oball, model 11486, is a lower-budget, 4-inch ball with openings to hold. Its rattle sections are hard plastic, so it is not an all-soft toy. Original Winkel, model 200930, has flexible loops around a quiet rattle, but its roughly 5-inch shape can be awkward for smaller hands. Both are labeled from birth; either can remain useful beyond the newborn stage.
Choose the shape you prefer to try, rather than buying both to cover different months. If your baby already handles a suitable rattle comfortably, there is little reason to replace it. Both picks need surface cleaning: use a damp cloth and mild soap for the Teal Oball without immersing it, and follow Winkel's surface-washing instructions without soaking, boiling, steaming or microwaving it.
Small and washable, or larger for floor play?
For fabric play, the clearest choice is between easy packing and a larger floor toy. Original Baby Paper in Black and White Stripes is a roughly 6-by-6-inch crinkly fabric square. It can fit into a bag without taking the space of a bulky activity toy, and the manufacturer permits machine washing, with low tumble drying or air drying. That makes it a useful option if you want a small washable item to offer during play.
It is quite loud when crinkled. Some babies manage it readily; others find the small square awkward, so do not buy it on a promise of an easier grip. Check its seams before use and after washing, and stop using it if damaged. It is not a dedicated teether. If you already have an age-appropriate washable crinkle toy that your baby likes, keep using it.
Melissa & Doug Flip Fish, item 9195, gives you more to explore together on the floor: crinkly scales, pictures underneath and a squeaker in the tail. At about 13.5 inches long, it is a larger object to set beside your baby, rather than a small toy to carry in one hand. You can lift a scale or crinkle it while your baby looks and touches; they do not need to open every flap or work the squeaker themselves.
I would choose Flip Fish for a baby who enjoys fabric toys when you want a larger one for shared floor play. Its main tradeoff is care: it is surface clean only. Baby Paper is the more practical choice when machine washing and packing small matter most. There is no need to add both, particularly if a cloth book already provides the textures and sounds your baby enjoys.
Reuse a gym, or buy one for the setup you want
Keep a suitable play gym you already own, following its instructions as your baby's movements change. If you are buying one now and want a musical setup, Fisher-Price Glow and Grow Kick & Play, Blue model HVX56, combines a mat, hanging toys and a piano. You are choosing a bigger play area with music, not filling a gap that every three-month-old has.
The mat is fairly thin, and the parts have different cleaning needs. The mat and soft toys can go through a cold gentle wash and low tumble dry; wipe the piano, arch and hard pieces. Follow the assembly instructions, keep it on the floor and do not add strings or improvised attachments. A simpler play area may suit you better if you do not want another large item. Do not put the gym in a crib or playpen.
Pictures can stay; later-age toys can wait
Pictures can stay in use too. Hold a card or picture book while you talk with your baby, keeping paper out of their mouth. There is no need to replace a black-and-white set just because your baby has turned three months. A suitable infant mirror you already own can also be used during awake, supervised play; check that it is intact and all packaging film has been removed.
Leave toys labeled 6m+ until that minimum age, even if your younger baby has started reaching. For sore gums, the FDA recommends a firm, unfilled rubber teether; choose one with an appropriate age label, follow its care instructions and do not freeze it. Gently massaging the gums with a clean finger is another option. A teether is a separate choice for discomfort, not a required addition to this toy list.
Keep all these toys for awake, supervised play and out of the sleep space. Pause when your baby has had enough, and stop using damaged items. If you are worried about development or your baby loses a skill, contact their clinician rather than trying to address the concern by buying another toy. For the earliest weeks, the 0–3 month guide compares first purchases.
Browse Best Toys by Age